Ryan Murphy’s True Crime Problem Is Getting Worse | Commentary

Both “Monsters” and “American Sports Story” show how Ryan Murphy’s melodramatic approach to true crime is failing real-life victims

monsters-Nicholas-Chavez-Cooper-Koch-Javier-Bardem-miles-cris-netflix
Nicholas Chavez, Cooper Koch and Javier Bardem in "Monsters: The Lyle And Erik Menendez Story" (Credit: Miles Crist/Netflix)

The Ryan Murphy TV empire is one of the most indomitable in modern entertainment. As Peak TV came to define a new era of small-screen programming, Murphy’s blend of frenetic excess and respectability made him a safe bet for success. He also became a critical darling, as true-life reimaginings of 20th century history in “American Crime Story” made him an Emmys favorite. 

While Murphy has not abandoned the high-aesthetic camp of “American Horror Story,” his most notable offerings of recent years have been rooted in the tricky genre of true crime. This month alone, the Murphy-verse has given us two true crime offerings: “American Sports Story,” a new FX series on the life and crimes of football player Aaron Hernandez, and the second season of “Monster”, focusing on the Menendez brothers.

Comments